Recent protests demanding accountability on exam-paper leaks resulted in the resignation of India’s central education minister in July and set some rare precedents. Among these include the rise of alternative digital mediums for citizen voices, Gen-Z or youth-led activism, disenchantment for the mainstream news media outlets, broad consensus on inadequacy of government-citizen engagements, vast political vacuum among political parties among the young, and now-proven large generation gap among citizenry.

Sonam Wangchuk Hunger Strike
New Playbook, Same Trend!
Moving out of these silos, in my opinion, the protests can not be termed as entirely a disconnected trend. Protests have been part of Indian politics, even after the emergence of the majoritarian BJP-led government. Let me elaborate with a sequence of protests that have slipped the public memory. A good read for this may be a left-leaning opinionated book, “ India on the move: When Jai Shri Ram met Bharata Mata ki Jai” by Marya Shakil and Narendra Nath Mishra. The book tries to make a balanced posturing describing protests such as 2016 JNU protests, when the country’s mood was overtly nationalist. I agree with the author that using nationalist and cultural symbols to counter protestors is not developmental. But! The protestors were using a non-partisan topic to target a newly-elected party and there was a fair deal of misinformation on both sides. The ruling party’s use of calling dissenters as “anti-national” was just beginning in 2016 and some protestors in JNU gave plenty of excuses for the same. Following 2016, the demonization of JNU as some would call it, was visible in plenty across media discourses. I remember a friend once said that this institution will be closed soon! JNU is the second best university, according to NIRF rankings.

JNU Protests
Challenge Like No Other!
The next massive protest that rocked the country was the farmers’ protests in 2021 following the passage of three new Farmer Laws to modernize the ailing sector. This protest had everything embedded in it- part Gandhian, part funded, part violent, mostly regional, partly representing certain class interests, politically-motivated, part-religious, etc. If the line seems confusing, imagine the agriculture sector. 2/3rd of India relies on Agriculture and almost half of families are entirely dependent on farming. 8 out of 10 farmers in the country mostly practice sustenance farming, i.e. half of India’s families remain grossly vulnerable to seasonal rains, disasters, economic instability and other factors. Not to mention the inadequate literacy and dependence on legacy agriculture systems followed in India. It is EVIDENT that anything that is new and private would be viewed with a deep sense of distrust by these farming communities. In the agriculture supply chain, there are wide disparities in income and power as well. Class-interests are too dominant and political interests are widely varying. In the above context, it was actually impressive that the farm protests were not national in tendency. Most of the farm unions actively protesting at Delhi’s Ghazipur gates were concentrated from 3-4 states namely Punjab, Haryana, parts of Western UP and Northern Rajasthan. There was a very active participation from Punjab. Thus, the Sikh angle was confusing for many and Khalistan remained a contentious hot topic. The government’s apathy in meeting protests in early weeks was a big mistake. Later, the BJP-led government repealed the farm bills. I have no opinions on why it did so! In the context of the recent resignation of the education minister, the repealing of farm laws was a much larger concession by the Modi-led government.

Farmers Protest
A Small but Strong Blitzkreig
Connected to farmer community by representation, but representing an entirely different sentiment, 2023 saw India’s wrestlers taking the protest-mat alleging sexual harassment (and other administrative issues) by the then head of the Wrestling Federation of India (WFI). I am not sure how politically motivated these protests were, but the suspension of WFI shows the state of affairs. Additionally, corruption has been a consistent issue in sports administration across the country, just like most developing countries. Coming back to topic, it may come as a surprise to today’s youth but a small section of sportspersons actually stirred a very emotional campaign backed by iron-clad will of their akhadas (wrestling arenas are seen with respect by this community in India). The government met the protestors half-way, although after its own attempt at wrestling via the Delhi Police.

It is my humble opinion that protests are not new in India and the current one by Gen-Z is one of many, rather than one apart from many. There have been protests against land reforms, industrial projects, climate change, animal rights, human rights violations, etc. The current government has not been exceptionally different from predecessors as well. In their own way of nationalist-led agendas, they tend to include domestic concerns. It is a no-brainer that such practices were actively predicted and out-smarted eventually. India remains a democracy through and through. The crisis it faces shifts and the standards of public changes, just like other democracies. BJP looks fairly situated among other political parties in the country with regards to its behaviour. Like Atal ji said, “Political parties are all similar. Small differences set them apart.”
What next!
As a person chasing International Politics for half a decade, I often wonder what great outcome can transpire from domestically politicizing issues with other countries! The answer lies in the open and history is often a good reminder. There have been many other protests in the previous decade, and they may have gone unnoticed among most people. Just like hundreds of other protests during the Congress-led government! BJP’s filter of nationalist words used overtly in domestic politics has run its full course. And it must be shelved for greater good and used only in times of need. India is a prisoner of geography and she shall see tensions with neighbours from time to time. With geopolitical rifts opening-up in Europe, Gulf, and global trade; there must be consensus among political leaders on how New Delhi can navigate its best interests ahead. Tumult is only oppurtunity in crisis.




Let us know what you think.